Pizza in New York
Independent pizza in Buffalo, NY
Who Wants Pizza? lists 43 independent pizza places in Buffalo, NY. National chains are left out. We checked 3 of them by hand, with their price and background. The rest come from OpenStreetMap and aren't checked yet, so call before you go. Tap any place for directions, or ask Pizza Bestie for the closest spot that makes a style you want.
Last updated October 15, 2026
Which pizza spots in Buffalo did we check by hand?
Pizza styles in Buffalo
Where can I get pizza in Buffalo?
From OpenStreetMap, a free public map. Not checked by Who Wants Pizza? yet: no prices, hours or ratings, so call before you go. Closest to downtown first.
- JJ's Casa-Di-Pizza11 East Mohawk Street, Buffalo, NY 14203🗺️ Directions
- Pizza Plant Italian Pub125 Main Street, Buffalo, NY 14203🗺️ Directions
- Bflo Pizza Bistro388 Porter Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14201🗺️ Directions
- Hydraulic Hearth716 Swan Street, Buffalo, NY 14210🗺️ Directions
- Extra Extra549 West Utica Street, Buffalo, NY 14213🗺️ Directions
- Fry Baby Donut Co69 Chenango Street, Buffalo, NY 14213🗺️ Directions
- Parivaar Pub708 Elmwood Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14222🗺️ Directions
- Gino's NY Pizzeria1009 Elmwood Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14222🗺️ Directions
- Mister Pizza1065 Elmwood Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14222🗺️ Directions
- Wally's Cafe and Pizzeria2083 Broadway Street, Buffalo, NY 14212🗺️ Directions
- Mineo's South Pizzaria2154 South Park Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14220🗺️ Directions
- Avenue Pizza & Pasta1116 Hertel Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14216🗺️ Directions
- Fontana's Pizza & Sandwich Shoppe77 South Rossler Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14206🗺️ Directions
- Route 62 Pizzeria3337 Bailey Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14215🗺️ Directions
- Hoagie Hounds301 Englewood Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14223🗺️ Directions
- Santora's Pizza Pub & Grill1 Walden Galleria Drive, Buffalo, NY 14225🗺️ Directions
- Tony's Pizzeria3680 Harlem Road, Buffalo, NY 14215🗺️ Directions
- Pie-O-Mine / Greens1725 Sheridan Drive, Buffalo, NY 14223🗺️ Directions
- Mattina's Pizzeria3744 Delaware Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14217🗺️ Directions
- Blasdell Pizza3904 South Park Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14219🗺️ Directions
- Pizza Delight3324 Sheridan Drive, Buffalo, NY 14226🗺️ Directions
- Zahz Pizza596 Cayuga Road, Buffalo, NY 14225🗺️ Directions
- Bocce Club Pizza4200 Genesee Street, Buffalo, NY 14225🗺️ Directions
- Anchor Bar4300 Maple Road, Buffalo, NY 14226🗺️ Directions
- Mo'z Pizza & Wings4621 Maple Road, Buffalo, NY 14226🗺️ Directions
- Forno Napoli1280 Sweet Home Road, Buffalo, NY 14228🗺️ Directions
- Picasso's Pizza4154 McKinley Parkway, Buffalo, NY 14219🗺️ Directions
- Sorrentinos5640 Main Street, Buffalo, NY 14221🗺️ Directions
- Schifano's Pizzeria4923 Genesee Street, Buffalo, NY 14225🗺️ Directions
- Papa's Pizza2675 Niagara Falls Boulevard, Buffalo, NY 14228🗺️ Directions
- Picasso's Pizza6812 Transit Road, Buffalo, NY 14221🗺️ Directions
- Mattina's Pizzeria6040 Sheridan Drive, Buffalo, NY 14221🗺️ Directions
- Pesci's Pizza & Wings8065 Main Street, Buffalo, NY 14221🗺️ Directions
- My Tomato Pie3035 Niagara Falls Boulevard, Buffalo, NY 14228🗺️ Directions
- Duff's Famous Wings4545 Transit Road, Buffalo, NY 14221🗺️ Directions
- Pizza Plant Italian Pub7770 Transit Road, Buffalo, NY 14221🗺️ Directions
- Santora's Pizza Pub & Grill7800 Transit Road, Buffalo, NY 14221🗺️ Directions
- Favorites Pizza & Wings3034 Sweet Home Road, Buffalo, NY 14228🗺️ Directions
- John's Pizza & Subs680 Campbell Boulevard, Buffalo, NY 14228🗺️ Directions
- Rocco’s Pizza5433 Transit Road, Buffalo, NY 14221🗺️ Directions
Places © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL). Something wrong or missing? Email [email protected]. All cities