Old Forge · Old Forge, PA
Old Forge pizza in Old Forge, PA
We checked 4 Old Forge spots in Old Forge, PA by hand: Revello's Pizza, Arcaro & Genell, Ghigiarelli's and Salerno's Cafe. Each one shows its price sign and background, with directions in one tap.
Last updated October 15, 2026
Where can I get Old Forge pizza in Old Forge?
Arcaro & Genell$$
Old Forge · Old Forge, PA
Red, white and peasant trays. Call ahead: takeout-first right now.
Ghigiarelli's$$
Old Forge · Old Forge, PA
Back in 2026. Takeout window. Sells out — go early.
What is Old Forge pizza?
Pizza Capital of the World. Order a TRAY, not a pie. Cut in squares — called “cuts”. Red tray: sauce + cheese. White: double crust, often rosemary. Old Forge, PA (near Scranton).